great western trail 2nd edition review

Great Western Trail 2nd Edition Board Game Review


Name: Great Western Trail 2nd Edition

BGG Weight: 3.70 / 5

Year Published: 2021

Publisher: Stronghold Games

Designer: Alexander Pfister

Number of Players: 2-4

Playing Time: 75-150 minutes

Game Category/Theme: Western, Cattle Drive, Deck Building, Hand Management

Mechanics: Deck, Bag, and Pool Building, Hand Management, Ownership, Set Collection, Solo / Solitaire Game



Strategy: 9.1

Complexity: 7.6

Player Interaction: 8.7

Replayability: 9.4

Game Rating: 9.2

Cost: 7.0



Weight Rating = 7.6 + 9.1 = 16.7

Playability Rating = [(9.4 + 8.7 + 9.2) – 7.6] = 19.7

Play Rating Score = (16.7 + 19.7) x 2 = 72.8

Value Rating = 72.8 / 7.0 = 10.4


Final Score Rating = 72.8 + 10.4 = 83.2



Great Western Trail 2nd Edition is an excellent game that combines elements of deck building, hand management, and worker placement in a unique and engaging way. Players take on the role of cattle drivers in the Old West, traveling from Texas to Kansas City to deliver their herds and earn money. Along the way, they must hire workers, manage their hands of cards, and make strategic decisions to maximize their profits.

One of the strengths of the game is the depth of strategy it offers. There are numerous paths to victory, and players must carefully balance their decisions to optimize their chances of success. The game also has a high level of player interaction, with players often competing for spaces on the board and trying to block their opponents’ progress.

Despite its complexity, Great Western Trail 2nd Edition is also highly replayable. The deck building aspect of the game means that each game is different, as players must adapt to the cards they are dealt and make the best use of them. The game also offers multiple paths to victory, so players can try out different strategies and approaches in each game.


Overall, Great Western Trail 2nd Edition is an excellent game that offers a high level of depth and strategy. It is not a game for beginners, but for experienced gamers who enjoy complex and challenging games, it is a must-play.

The game does not offer solo or cooperative play, so it is strictly a competitive game.


If someone enjoyed Great Western Trail 2nd Edition, they may also enjoy the following games:

  1. Terraforming Mars: A strategy game where players take on the role of corporations trying to terraform Mars. Players must manage resources and build infrastructure to achieve their goals.
  2. Scythe: A strategy game set in an alternate history 1920s Europe. Players compete to control territory and resources, while building their armies and completing objectives.
  3. Viticulture: A worker placement game where players manage a vineyard and compete to produce the best wine. Players must manage their workers and resources to achieve their goals.
  4. Gloomhaven: A cooperative dungeon-crawling game with legacy elements. Players must work together to complete quests and fight monsters, while unlocking new content as they progress.
  5. Everdell: A worker placement game set in a fantasy world. Players must build their cities and compete to complete objectives, while managing their resources and workers.
  6. Wingspan: A card-driven game where players collect birds and build habitats.

This review was provided by Open Source Artificial Intelligence programs.  It uses a series of complex statement to have AI programs amalgomate their databases to produces information on board games.  These reviews are completely unedited output from the AI bots.